Hierarchy of Control: ERIC-PD Explained with Site Examples
The hierarchy of control explained for UK sites: elimination, substitution, engineering, admin controls and PPE, with ERIC-PD and worked RAMS examples.

Plenty of RAMS for cutting paving slabs still list the dust control as "FFP3 mask to be worn". Nothing about water suppression, on-tool extraction or ordering the slabs cut to size. The mask is the last thing the law expects you to reach for, and here it's the first and only control on the page.
The hierarchy of control is the order you work through when deciding how to control a risk: eliminate the hazard, substitute something less hazardous, use engineering controls, then administrative controls, and only then personal protective equipment (PPE). The controls at the top are more effective and more reliable because they don't depend on people getting it right every time. In UK law, the idea comes from the general principles of prevention in Schedule 1 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999, and the same order appears in COSHH, the Work at Height Regulations and the PPE at Work Regulations.
This guide explains where the hierarchy comes from, what ERIC-PD means, and how each level looks on real construction, security and FM jobs.
Where the hierarchy of control comes from in UK law
You won't find the words "hierarchy of control" as a heading in the main regulations. What you will find is the same principle written into several of them.
MHSWR 1999: the principles of prevention
Regulation 4 of MHSWR says that when an employer puts preventive and protective measures in place, they must do it on the basis of the principles in Schedule 1. There are nine. The ones that shape the hierarchy are:
- (a) avoiding risks, which is elimination.
- (b) evaluating the risks which cannot be avoided, which is your risk assessment.
- (c) combating the risks at source, which points to engineering controls rather than protecting the person.
- (f) replacing the dangerous by the non-dangerous or the less dangerous, which is substitution.
- (h) giving collective protective measures priority over individual protective measures, so guardrails before harnesses.
- (i) giving appropriate instructions to employees, which sits in administrative controls.
Our MHSWR 1999 guide covers the rest of the regulations.
COSHH regulation 7
The Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002 set out the clearest version. Regulation 7 says exposure must be prevented or, where that isn't reasonably practicable, adequately controlled. Substitution is the preferred way to prevent exposure. Where prevention isn't reasonably practicable, the measures come in a set order: suitable work processes, systems and engineering controls first, then control at source such as ventilation and organisational measures, and PPE only where adequate control can't be achieved by other means. More in our COSHH regulations guide.
Work at Height Regulations 2005
Regulation 6 has its own hierarchy: avoid work at height where it's reasonably practicable to do the job safely another way, then prevent falls, then minimise the distance and consequences of a fall if one can't be prevented. See our working at height regulations guide.
PPE at Work Regulations 1992
Regulation 4 requires suitable PPE except where the risk has been adequately controlled by other means that are equally or more effective. The HSE puts it plainly: PPE should be regarded as the last resort. Since April 2022 those duties also cover limb (b) workers. Our PPE at Work Regulations guide covers the rest.
ERIC-PD and the five-step hierarchy of control
You'll see two versions on training courses and in RAMS. They say the same thing in slightly different words.
The five-step version:
- Elimination
- Substitution
- Engineering controls
- Administrative controls
- Personal protective equipment
ERIC-PD, which is common in UK construction training:
- Eliminate
- Reduce (or replace with something less hazardous)
- Isolate
- Control
- PPE
- Discipline
The "D" is a reminder that none of the controls work unless they're followed, supervised and enforced. Neither acronym appears in legislation, so use whichever your team knows. What matters is that you work down from the top and only move to the next level once you've properly considered the one above.
The five levels with site examples
1. Elimination
Remove the hazard completely. It's the most effective control because once the hazard's gone, nobody can be hurt by it.
- Construction: assemble roof trusses or steel sections at ground level and lift them into place, so fewer people work at height. Design a service route so it doesn't need a deep excavation next to a building.
- FM: move air handling plant from the roof to a ground-level plant room during a refit, so routine maintenance no longer involves roof access.
- Security: install remote monitoring on a vacant building so a mobile patrol officer doesn't have to walk an unlit interior at night.
Elimination is often only possible at design or planning stage. That's why CDM 2015 requires designers to eliminate foreseeable risks so far as is reasonably practicable.
2. Substitution
Replace the hazard with something less hazardous.
- Use water-based paints or adhesives instead of solvent-based ones in an occupied building.
- Use 25kg bags instead of heavier ones, or blocks with a lower unit weight. Lighter loads cut the manual handling risk at source.
- Choose low-vibration tools, or a block splitter instead of a cut-off saw. See our HAVS assessment guide.
- Use a battery-powered tool rather than a petrol one in an enclosed space, so there's no exhaust.
- For a cleaning contractor, switch to a less hazardous product that does the same job.
Watch that the substitute doesn't bring in a new hazard. COSHH's principles of good practice make the point that control measures shouldn't increase the overall risk.
3. Engineering controls
Change the workplace or equipment to separate people from the hazard. These are collective controls: they protect everyone, not just the person wearing something.
- Water suppression or on-tool extraction on saws and grinders cutting silica-containing materials.
- Edge protection and guardrails on a flat roof, rather than relying on harnesses.
- Physical barriers separating pedestrians from plant and vehicle routes.
- Local exhaust ventilation (LEV) in a workshop or for welding.
- Guards and interlocks on machinery.
- At events, crowd barriers and designed queuing lanes rather than relying on stewards alone.
4. Administrative controls
Change the way people work. These rely on people following them, which is why they sit below engineering controls.
- A permit to work for hot works, confined spaces or electrical isolation.
- A written safe system of work and method statement.
- Job rotation to cut each person's daily vibration exposure.
- Exclusion zones, signage and banksmen.
- Training, supervision and toolbox talks.
- Lone worker check-in procedures for security officers and FM engineers.
5. Personal protective equipment
PPE protects only the person wearing it, and only when it fits, is suitable for the hazard, is in good condition and is worn properly the whole time. Face-fit testing for tight-fitting respiratory protection, hearing protection that's actually worn in the noisy area, and harnesses that are inspected and correctly anchored all matter.
PPE is still essential on most jobs. It's just not meant to be the main control when something higher up is reasonably practicable.
Why the higher controls are more reliable
It comes down to how much each control depends on people. Elimination and substitution don't depend on anyone. Engineering controls work as long as they're maintained. Administrative controls need people to follow a procedure every time. PPE needs the individual to wear the right item, correctly, for the whole exposure.
That's why a guardrail beats a harness, and why water suppression beats a dust mask. You'll usually use a combination. The HSE's COSHH guidance makes the point that good control is often a mix of options. But the higher controls should be doing most of the work.
Using the hierarchy of control in a RAMS
When you're writing or reviewing a RAMS, work through each significant hazard like this:
- Can the hazard be eliminated? If not, note briefly why.
- Can something less hazardous be used instead?
- What engineering controls can be put in place?
- What procedures, permits, training and supervision are needed?
- What PPE is needed for the risk that's left?
- Does any control create a new hazard?
Recording why a higher control wasn't reasonably practicable helps show your thinking to a principal contractor, client or inspector.
Worked example: cutting kerbs on a highways job
- Eliminate: order radius kerbs and specials so fewer cuts are needed on site.
- Substitute: use a block splitter where the cut allows, instead of a cut-off saw.
- Engineering: water suppression on the saw, with a supply that lasts the whole task.
- Administrative: trained operatives only, an exclusion zone around the cutting area, and scheduling to limit time on the saw.
- PPE: face-fit tested respiratory protection, eye protection, hearing protection and gloves.
Worked example: replacing lamps in a high atrium
- Eliminate or reduce: fit long-life LED fittings or lowering gear so access is needed less often, or not at all.
- Engineering: a MEWP with guardrails rather than ladders.
- Administrative: out-of-hours working, a cordoned area below, and a trained operator with a rescue plan.
- PPE: harness with a short restraint lanyard in a boom-type MEWP, plus hard hats for anyone in the area below.
Common mistakes
- PPE first. Listing a mask or harness as the main control when an engineering control is available.
- Generic controls. "Take care" and "be aware of surroundings" aren't controls.
- Controls not linked to hazards. Each control should clearly deal with a specific hazard.
- No reasoning. Not recording why higher-level controls weren't used.
- Forgetting the "D". Good controls on paper that nobody checks on site.
How swiftRMS helps
swiftRMS drafts RAMS for construction, security and FM work, built around the principles of prevention in MHSWR 1999. Each draft sets out hazards with control measures and cites the relevant legislation, so your reviewer is starting from a structured document rather than a blank page. You can see the format in our example RAMS.
It's a draft, ready for review. A competent person still needs to check the controls against the actual site, move anything up the hierarchy that can be, edit what doesn't fit, and approve it before work starts. For work with hazardous substances, see how swiftRMS handles COSHH assessments.
To see what a draft looks like for one of your own jobs, try a free RAMS preview with no signup. If it works for your team, there's a 14-day free trial with no card needed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the 5 levels of the hierarchy of control?
Elimination, substitution, engineering controls, administrative controls and personal protective equipment. You work from the top down, using the most effective control that's reasonably practicable, and often combine several.
What does ERIC-PD stand for?
Eliminate, Reduce (or replace), Isolate, Control, PPE and Discipline. It's a UK training version of the hierarchy of control. The "Discipline" step is a reminder that controls only work if they're followed and supervised.
Is the hierarchy of control a legal requirement?
The phrase isn't used as such, but the principle is in law. MHSWR 1999 regulation 4 requires employers to apply the principles of prevention in Schedule 1, and COSHH regulation 7, the Work at Height Regulations 2005 and the PPE at Work Regulations 1992 all set a preferred order of controls.
Why is PPE the last resort?
It protects only the wearer, and only when it's the right type, fits properly, is maintained and is worn for the whole exposure. If any of those fail, the person is unprotected. Controls higher up protect everyone and don't rely on individual behaviour.
Where does training fit in the hierarchy?
Training is an administrative control. It's needed on almost every job, but it doesn't remove or reduce the hazard itself, so it shouldn't be the main control where elimination, substitution or engineering controls are reasonably practicable.
Can I skip straight to PPE if the job is short?
Short duration doesn't change the order. You still need to consider the higher controls first. For a brief task some of them may not be reasonably practicable, but that should be a decision you've thought through and can explain, not an assumption.
Official Resources
- MHSWR 1999, Schedule 1: general principles of prevention (legislation.gov.uk)
- COSHH 2002, regulation 7: prevention or control of exposure (legislation.gov.uk)
- Work at Height Regulations 2005, regulation 6 (legislation.gov.uk)
- Risk assessment: steps needed to manage risk (HSE)
- COSHH: principles of good control practice (HSE)
- PPE at Work Regulations: 2022 changes (HSE)
Recommended Tools & Resources
Save hours on health & safety paperwork — generate documents with swiftRMS.
Create a professional RAMS in under 2 minutes — UK legislation cited automatically.
From £49/mo. CDM 2015 referenced. 14-day free trial, no card needed.
The UK RAMS tools side by side: features, pricing and speed.
12+ trade-specific UK risk assessment templates with hazards and legislation.